The Girl Next Door follows Eve, a British ex-pat who moved to New York because of her husband's job, and the people who live in her new building on the Upper East Side. Eve must learn to adjust to the lonliness of being surrounded by 20 million people, but each of the residents in her building have something to learn, as well. Some neighbors interact with each other; most don't, save for a nod in the hallway. Some are major characters who play as prominent a role in the book as Eve; others are only mentioned in passing. What Noble did well was to take the idea that we are all extras in the movie of someone else's life and explore how our own individual lives affect others'. Because the story is told from the point of view of many different residents of the building, the reader often gets to view the same situation from different vantage points.
In The Brightest Star in the Sky, however, the residents of an apartment townhouse in Dublin are observed by a not-so-neutral observer. The ethereal narrator has been told that this particular townhouse is the one to choose from, and so must observe the couples that live at or are connected to this address. In the narrator's quest to pick the best couple, the characters' facades slowly crumble to reveal what they are hiding within their walls. The premise of using the residents of one building is an interesting way to get a diverse group of characters to interact. Both of these books told interesting stories with a lot of heart.













